Option 1 Recommended
Browse our online buylist, add the cards you want to sell, and submit your list ahead of time. We’ll have your offer ready when you arrive. No waiting around.
Open online buylist →Option 2
Prefer to bring everything in and let us sort through it? No problem. Walk in during store hours and we’ll evaluate your cards on the spot. No appointment needed.
Mon–Fri 3–10pm • Sat 12–10pm • Sun 12–6pm
Walk in during store hours with your singles, sealed product, or collection. No sorting required, we’ll do the work.
Our staff evaluates condition using industry-standard grading and prices based on current market value (TCGPlayer).
Accept our offer and walk out with cash or store credit. Store credit always receives a bonus percentage.
Singles we accept
Other items we buy
We grade every card carefully using the following conditions. When a card falls between grades, we grade conservatively to protect both parties.
| Grade | What it means | Buylist rate |
|---|---|---|
| Near Mint (NM) | Essentially perfect. May have minor handling marks not visible from arm’s length. No creases, scratches, or whitening. | Full rate |
| Lightly Played (LP) | Minor edge wear, light scuffs, or slight whitening on corners. Playable without sleeves but shows use. | ~80% of NM rate |
| Moderately Played (MP) | Noticeable wear on edges and corners, minor surface scratches, or light creasing. Still tournament legal in sleeves. | ~60% of NM rate |
| Heavily Played (HP) | Significant wear, creases, or damage. Still identifiable and functional, but visibly distressed. | ~40% of NM rate |
| Damaged (D) | Severe creasing, water damage, tears, or writing on the card. | Case by case |
Store credit Best value
Receive store credit at a bonus percentage above the cash rate. Use it on anything in the store: singles, sealed, accessories, event entry. Credit never expires.
Cash
Walk out with cash the same day. For purchases over $100, a valid government-issued photo ID is required per Ohio secondhand dealer regulations.
ID requirements
For any buylist transaction with a total cash value of $100 or more, Ohio law requires us to collect and record a valid government-issued photo ID. Accepted forms of ID include:
This information is collected solely for compliance with Ohio Revised Code requirements for secondhand dealers and is kept securely on file.
A note on counterfeit cards
We test all cards for authenticity using print line inspection, light and texture tests, and weight checking. If we believe a card is not genuine, we will politely decline to purchase it and explain our reasoning. We will never accuse you of wrongdoing, counterfeit cards are widespread in the hobby and often unknowingly passed on by sellers.
Ready to sell? Come see us.
Mon – Fri: 3:00pm – 10:00pm • Saturday: 12:00pm – 10:00pm • Sunday: 12:00pm – 6:00pm
538 Main St, Wintersville, Ohio • (740) 346-0630